They’re all basically the same concept, with a happy sheep coming toward the camera. Prompting for a video is different from prompting for an image; I struggled to get good results in the limited number of generations available to me. I had more failures than successes.
Here are a couple of fails where I tried to get a video of Moses parting the Red Sea. The first one looks like a video game cutscene, but revealing a giant wall is opposite of what I’m going for. In the second one, Moses decides to take a quick dip in the Red Sea before popping back out. Both of them are trying (and failing) to create the “wall of water” effect popularized by the movie The Ten Commandments.
If I had more credits available, I’d share more. We’re in the earliest days of text-to-video generations—the DALLE-2 era of AI videos: they’re amazing but limited, advanced but (in retrospect) basic.
Acts 27 recounts Paul’s shipwreck as he travels from Crete to Malta after Yom Kippur (September 24 in AD 60, approximately when this story is set). For the shipwreck portion of the voyage, his ship starts in Fair Havens on the southern of coast of Crete. They’re trying to make port in western Crete but are blown by a strong wind from the northeast. The sailors are concerned about being driven into sandbars in the gulf of Syrtis, so they let the ship be blown along and eventually end up in Malta.
On November 11, 2021, Storm Blas set up this wind pattern almost exactly, connecting Crete to Malta (the strong white line represents my interpretation of a possible path):
This wind pattern comes from the mesmerizing earth.nullschool.net, where you can also play around with an animated version. (It’s way more exciting than this static image). This image reflects a point in time, while Paul’s shipwreck narrative takes two weeks. So this wind pattern would change during the voyage; this image just happens to show the appropriate wind pattern for the whole voyage.
Arguably, the wind should blow them farther south, closer to Syrtis. Cyclone Zorbas from September 27, 2018, shows an even-more-intense flow that would take a ship nearer Syrtis. It doesn’t connect to Malta, but, again, the wind patterns would change over the course of several days.
Earlier in the story, Luke describes sailing from Sidon “under the lee of Cyprus, because the winds were against us.” Then they “sailed across the open sea along the coast of Cilicia and Pamphylia” on the way to Myra. Bible maps don’t entirely agree what “the lee of Cyprus” implies for the route (some take it to mean sailing along Cyprus’s southern coast, though that interpretation creates tension with “Cilicia and Pamphylia” to the north). This image from October 29, 2023, illustrates the lee along Cyprus’s eastern coast:
Finally, the trip from Myra to Cnidus (“with difficulty”) and then to Salmone on Crete (“the wind did not allow us to go farther”) could find an expression on October 13, 2024. In this image, the winds during the segment from Myra to Cnidus are coming from the west or northwest, against the direction of travel. The strong winds from the north through the Aegean make westward travel difficult, pushing the ship south. This wind pattern appears to be typical for this time of year.
Again, I’m not arguing that these images reflect the actual wind patterns involved in Paul’s shipwreck voyage; I’m just showing that it’s possible to find modern analogues to the winds described in the story.
Posted in Geo, Visualizations | Comments Off on Visualizing the Wind Patterns Leading to Paul’s Shipwreck
Did you know that different translations insert section headings at different places in the Bible text? Some translations might want shorter sections to break up the text into more-easily digestible units, while others may prefer fewer sections to better preserve the flow of thought.
This project takes twenty English Bibles (BSB, ERV, ESV, ISV, NCV, CEB, CEV, CSB, GNT, GW, LEB, NABRE, NASB, NCB, NET, NIV, NKJV, NLT, NRSVue, and REB), identifies where each section starts and ends, and presents the aggregated data.
Specifically, it uses Sankey diagrams to plot section breaks for each book of the Bible. For example, here’s the diagram for Ruth (also in png format):
Here’s how to read this diagram: The height of each solid bar indicates the number of translations with a heading at that verse. Lighter bands emanate from each bar to where the section ends. For example, from 1:1, you can see a small band that ends at 1:7, larger bands that end at 1:14 and 2:1, and a much-larger band that ends at 1:6. The size of the bands shows the number of translations. So we can see that most translations treat 1:1-5 as a single section, and they start a new section at 1:6. Then, starting in 1:6, there’s much more variety in how long the sections are (you can see that the bands fan out to five different vertical bars).
What can we learn from this visualization? The high bars at 1:1, 2:1, 3:1, and 4:1 indicate that translations insert headings at the chapter breaks in Ruth. (Ruth is unusual in this respect; most books don’t break so cleanly and unanimously.) In chapter one, you can see somewhat-large divisions at verses 6 (Naomi hears about God’s work) and 19 (Ruth and Naomi arrive in Bethlehem). But other translations pick different divisions in chapter 1: verse 7 (Naomi starts heading out to Bethlehem), verse 8 (Naomi asks her daughters-in-law to go back, verse 14 (Ruth clings to Naomi), verse 16 (“Where you go I will go”), and verse 18 (Naomi stops asking Ruth to go back). And still other translations don’t break up chapter one at all. So different translators see different moments as deserving headings, which shapes how you read the text.
Similarly, in chapter four, many translations see 4:13 as a turning point (when Boaz officially marries Ruth). The bar at 4:18 is showing that some translations have a heading for David’s genealogy, but most don’t.
Lamentations is another favorite. Some translations make the acrostic structure visible to the English reader through headings, but most don’t:
Is this kind of analysis helpful? I’m not really sure. And the data complexity for most books—Ruth is manageable, but longer books are less so—is perhaps pushing Sankey diagrams past where they’re useful. But explore and decide for yourself. As usual, the data is freely available to download under a CC-BY license. I used SankeyMATIC to generate the Sankey diagrams; you can click through to SankeyMATIC to interact with the diagrams by highlighting certain bands and moving things around.
Update: to follow on with my previous post, here are two AI-generated podcasters discussing these diagrams. The part where they discuss Exodus is especially interesting to me, since I don’t discuss it in the text. The only way they’d draw their conclusions is by looking at and understanding the Sankey diagram for Exodus, knowing that Exodus 32 is about the golden calf, and interpreting it as they do. It’s impressive. Listen here.
Here’s a conversation about the book of Galatians—all I did was give it a link to Bible Gateway, and it produced this fifteen-minute conversation:
This is, honestly, good. It has what I’d look for in an non-technical overview of Galatians, and it’s more-engaging to listen to than the typical sermon. It doesn’t go too in-depth, but it’s a strong overview.
In my intro to the AI Sermon Outline Generator, I said that the sermon outlines it generates are “around the 50th percentile” in terms of sermon quality, but I’d put this podcast closer to the 90th percentile, at least in terms of presentation. It’s engaging—very much like a natural conversation between two people who are discussing the text while bringing in perspectives and background information. It even includes personal application (a takeaway) the way a sermon would.
Listening to this discussion was ear-opening for me: it was better than nearly every sermon I’ve ever heard, but its insights are synthetic and not really aimed at me (or anyone). I didn’t hear anything that was wrong, but as with any AI, it could very easily make things up, misinterpret passages, or introduce subtle (or not-so-subtle) heresies. But it’s so engaging that I might not even notice.
Elisha and the Bears
Next, I gave it the difficult story of Elisha and the bears from 2 Kings 2:23-25:
Here it did a decent job of presenting some of the basic interpretive options, but I wouldn’t say it engaged that much with the text. It also didn’t really draw conclusions.
So I uploaded about 3,000 words of commentary material on this passage, and it produced the following:
This is definitely better, and it grounds it in more of the commentary text. Again its conclusion is that you need to figure out its meaning for yourself, which isn’t exactly what I’m looking for in a sermon. But it still did a good job of presenting background info and various interpretations.
Your Daily Bible Reading
Lastly, I uploaded today’s Daily Office reading; the Daily Office thematically arranges texts, so I expected it to draw out similarities between them. It didn’t disappoint:
I grant you, again, that it isn’t the deepest conversation. But it hit the themes and key verses in an engaging way; it did a good job providing thoughts around the text and making me care more about what I just read in the Bible. And, importantly, I could produce a similar podcast no matter what my passages were; it’s custom-generated for exactly what I’m reading.
What’s Are These Podcasts Useful For?
Because the podcasts are stylistically engaging, I think it might make sense for a pastor to upload a sermon’s Bible passages along with research materials into NotebookLM and have it generate a podcast about it. You can listen to it while you’re going for a walk or commuting somewhere. Then you can ask yourself questions like: What does the podcast focus on? How does it activate interest and curiosity in listeners the way podcasts do? The risk is that it’ll podcastify your sermon and move it toward becoming a podcast rather than a sermon. But if you struggle with sermon writing, it might give you some ideas on engaging your audience.
As for non-pastors, creating a podcast that directly relates to your regular Bible reading might be a way to help you think about the Bible text in a new way. It’s worth trying out if you find that you’re looking for something different.
Do They Make Sermons Obsolete?
I wouldn’t say that these podcasts make sermons obsolete, exactly, since they don’t serve the same purpose as a sermon. In terms of quality and keeping my interest, these podcasts surpass most sermons I’ve heard. In terms of depth and insight, they tend to pose questions more than provide answers, which is fine for the podcast genre but isn’t necessarily what I’m looking for in a sermon.
But I was still impressed: as custom, near-instant podcasts, they work really well—much better than I was expecting. Outside of church, I’m much more likely to listen to one of these podcasts than I am to a sermon, especially since I can ensure the podcast will cover exactly the topic I’m interested in and ground it in the sources I care about.
This year, the usual trio of Twitter, social networking, and alcohol led the list, with Twitter taking the #1 spot for the first time since 2021.
This report draws from 9,817 tweets, the lowest number of Tweets I’ve ever tracked and down from a high of 646,000 in 2014. It only took ten tweets to make the top 100 this year, compared to 228 that year. On the other hand, the list of items in the top 100 has remained fairly stable: 56 of the top items from 2014 are also in the 2024 list.
Relationships
With Ash Wednesday falling on Valentine’s Day this year for the first time since 2018 (next time will be 2029, and then not again until 2170), relationship-related tweets rose. This year saw an increase in “situationships,” though it didn’t reach the top 100.
Sin
Giving up sin had a big uptick this year. I don’t have an explanation.
The Press
U.S. President Joe Biden said that he was giving up “you guys” for Lent, a reference to reporters.
Taylor Swift
Only eight tweets mentioned celebrities this year; seven of them were for Taylor Swift.
Top 100 Things Twitterers Gave Up for Lent in 2024
As I write this post on Monday morning, with about 350 tweets analyzed, “social networking,” “twitter,” and “chocolate” lead the list.
This year, since it would cost me $5,000 to use Twitter’s API to track what’s previously been free for the Lent Tracker, I’m having to take a more manual and sampled approach to tweets, which also means the results won’t be available in realtime the way they have been in years past; you can expect them to be updated a few times per day.
Suno.ai does for music what DALL-E does for images: turn text into synthetic art. My first thought is that it could be helpful for memorizing the Bible: you enter in the text you want to memorize and the style of music that most helps you memorize (no judgment if that’s yodeling).
Here are three musical renderings (instruments and vocals) I made of Psalm 121 (NIV) in three different styles:
The quality isn’t quite there, but it’s pretty good.
If you’re looking for actual human-created musical approaches to memorizing Bible verses, I recommend Biblevox, which collects over 3,000 Bible-memory songs in one place and is run by my father’s brother’s nephew’s cousin’s former roommate, Ken Boer. (I do love a good data-categorization project.) Ken also pointed me to “I Am Better Than You,” which is a fun take on conveying the essence of Philippians 3:2-11–though it’s not, strictly speaking, a Bible-memory song.
Posted in AI, Music | Comments Off on Our New AI Worship-Music Overlords
The AI Sermon Outline Generator, released in January 2023, now uses GPT-4 Turbo (unveiled a week ago) to generate its thesis statements and outlines instead of GPT-3. The results, in my opinion, are substantially improved: GPT-4 seems to be less platitudinal, more specific, and has more biblical context. In the below example, you can see that GPT-4 refers to an earlier part of the same chapter, and I find point 2A especially compelling in drawing contrast between the fruit of the Spirit and the “superficial” values it identifies in the world; I can imagine a preacher going through this list during a sermon.
Generated outlines for Galatians 5:22-23 (the fruit of the Spirit) with the theme of “beauty”
Thesis: The fruit of the Spirit is a higher form of beauty than any outer beauty that does not reflect the Spirit’s character. 1. Thesis: The fruit of the Spirit is a higher form of beauty than any outer beauty that does not reflect the Spirit’s character.
2. Point: Our fallen state has caused us to be blind to the beauty of the Spirit. A. We are often drawn to the outer beauty of people and things. B. We are easily deceived by our own desires and the deceptions of the world. 3. Point: We can rediscover the beauty of the Spirit by embracing his fruit. A. The fruit of the Spirit is manifest in the character of Christ and his followers. B. These traits are rooted in the love of God and lead to peace, joy, and contentment. 4. Point: We must strive to be transformed by the Spirit in order to experience true beauty. A. We must allow the Spirit to change our hearts and minds. B. We must submit ourselves to the Spirit’s will in order to experience the true beauty of the Spirit.
Conclusion and Application: 1. The fruit of the Spirit is the highest form of beauty. 2. Our fallen state has caused us to be blind to the beauty of the Spirit. 3. We can rediscover the beauty of the Spirit by embracing his fruit and striving to be transformed by the Spirit.
Thesis: Cultivating the fruit of the Spirit in our lives is an act of defiance against the world’s superficial values, showcasing the enduring beauty of godly character that has no law against it.
Introduction: In a world obsessed with external appearances, God calls Christians to cultivate a beauty that comes from within.
1. The true beauty of the Christian life is the fruit of the Spirit, not worldly glamor. A. Galatians 5:22-23 describes the characteristics that define the essence of Christian inner beauty. B. This fruit is in contrast to the ‘acts of the flesh’ earlier in Galatians 5, highlighting a distinction from the world’s values.
2. Each aspect of the fruit of the Spirit defies the world’s superficial values, revealing the divine blueprint for human behavior. A. Love counters cultural self-centeredness, joy overcomes despair, peace contradicts chaos, patience resists immediacy, kindness opposes harshness, goodness defies corruption, faithfulness challenges fickleness, gentleness rebuts violence, and self-control tempers excess. B. Collectively, these qualities reveal the holiness of God and his transformative work in us.
3. The beauty of godly character, rooted in the Spirit, is timeless and universal, with no law against it. A. The concluding phrase ‘against such things there is no law’ asserts the eternal and unassailable nature of these virtues (Galatians 5:23). B. As believers grow in these qualities, they mirror the image of Christ and present a powerful witness to the world.
Conclusion: By intentionally nurturing the fruit of the Spirit, Christians display an inner beauty that reflects God’s love and transcends temporal, worldly aesthetics.
Some stats
The generator has created about 46,000 thesis statements and 14,000 outlines (with 6,500 expressing a denomination: 2,400 Baptist, 1,800 Pentecostal, and the other denominations all around 300) since its launch.
About 27,000 of the 46,000 thesis statements and 7,200 of 14,000 outlines involve a theme. Below are the most-popular ones. “Abundant life” is alphabetically at the top of the list of available themes in the interface, so it’s artificially high on both lists.
This year, the usual trio of alcohol, Twitter, and social networking led the list, with alcohol just outpacing Twitter.
This report draws from 12,891 tweets out of 386,048 total tweets mentioning Lent.
Vegetables
The increase in “tomatoes” and “vegetables” refers to the announcement that several large grocery stores in the UK will temporarily restrict the number of tomatoes, cucumbers, and peppers that customers can buy because of shortages.
Social Networks
TikTok continues its march upward, this year helped by news that some official EU bodies are banning it from staff devices. Meanwhile, Facebook continues its slide.
Hate
“Hate” and “being a hater” both had sharp increases this year, while “racism” declined.
Restaurants
Food delivery services continue to rise, while Chipotle overtakes Chick Fil A for the first time since 2016.
As I write this post, with about 660 tweets analyzed, perennial favorites “twitter,” “social networking,” and “alcohol” lead the list. Right now, “sugar” is at #5, a much-higher showing than it usually has; we’ll see if it holds its place through the week.
I expect “twitter” to run higher this year given some of its recent, polarizing decisions. Twitter has also talked about disabling its API, upon which the Twitter Lent Tracker depends, any day now, so hopefully the Tracker will survive the week.
